What the Moon Said

What the Moon Said Fans Of The Little House Books Will Fall In Love With EstherThanks To Her Superstitious Mother, Esther Knows Some Tricks For Avoiding Bad Luck Toss Salt Over Your Left Shoulder, Never Button Your Shirt Crooked, And Avoid Black Cats But Even Luck Can T Keep Her Family Safe From The Great Depression When Pa Loses His Job, Esther S Family Leaves Their Comfy Chicago Life Behind For A Farm In WisconsinLiving On A Farm Comes With Lots Of Hard Work, But That Means There Are Plenty Of Opportunities For Esther To Show Her Mother How Helpful She Can Be She Loves All Of The Farm Animals Except The Mean Geese And Even Better Makes A Fast Friend In Lively Bethany But Then Ma Sees A Sign That Esther Just Knows Is Wrong If Believing A Superstition Makes You Miserable, How Can That Be Good Luck Debut Author Gayle Rosengren Brings The Past To Life In This Extraordinary, Hopeful Story

Is a well-known author, some of his books are a fascination for readers like in the What the Moon Said book, this is one of the most wanted Gayle Rosengren author readers around the world.

[Reading] ➾ What the Moon Said  By Gayle Rosengren – Online-strattera-atomoxetine.info
  • Hardcover
  • 217 pages
  • What the Moon Said
  • Gayle Rosengren
  • 13 May 2017
  • 9780399163524

10 thoughts on “What the Moon Said

  1. says:

    Although I originally read this exquisite and heartwarming novel in 2014, I loved Gail Rosengren s What the Moon Said so much, I adored it so much that I simply have not been able to pen and post a for and to me adequate review Since the author is also a GR friend, I recently realised that I should really post a review, although I still think that any review I do post, will not even remotely come close to describing how much this book was and still is a pleasure and a joy to read I have reread it at least five times since 2014 and each time, I love and appreciate it even , and will than likely continue to do so Now I think one of the main reasons that I enjoyed What the Moon Said so very much is the fact that the father is German and the mother Russian or perhaps Russian Mennonite , but that even though the story takes place in 1930 s America, there is no all Germans are evil presented and shown it is simply a story about individuals, many of them of German background and mostly farmers trying to make ends meet, and how the whole community helps and sustains one another While I do have some rather huge issues with the mother and her strict and uncompromising ways, I actually also very much appreciate the fact that the author has not shied away from depicting her as a character with faults and problematic, superstitious ideas and one should indeed remember that the mother does, in fact, apologise and accept that she has made mistakes, and that alone, is worth gold in my opinion.Yes, What the Moon Said is, indeed, truly wonderful a real treasure and a perfect book for middle grade readers to read on their own or with their parents And truth be told, I actually adored What the Moon Said almost as much as the Anne of Green Gables series and those who know me should realise that this is probably the absolute highest praise I can give to a children s book Most highly recommended to anyone, and even many adults will likely find this book a lovely reading pleasure

  2. says:

    Do you know the saying, Don t judge a book by its cover Well, I totally do that, at least when it comes to actual books It s the first thing that draws me to a book, and I have a sneaking suspicion that I m not alone in this The cover wouldn t be so important otherwise, right Well, when I decided to review a new juvenile book middle grade to be exact , I scrolled through all the covers of new releases until this one struck me The cover was beautiful with the large moon hanging behind the title, and the little girl and her dog running across it lent a hopeful feeling The book blurb seemed promising so I gave it a shot Luckily for me, What the Moon Says was a stunning debut for Gayle Rosengren.When Esther s father loses his job in the city during the Depression, the family makes a hard move to a farm to try their hand, and luck, at farming and living off the land The book follows their ups and downs as they discover both the rewards and the heartaches of farm life Esther s mother is extremely superstitious and sees signs in almost everything The book isn t called What the Moon Says for nothing Esther s mother, or Ma as she calls her, dictates many decisions by the current position, shade, and so on, of the moon Her decisions often set the rest of the family either at ease or at incredible unease Ma, she said, pointing at the sky It s the moon And it s daytime How can that be Ma gazed up at the white circle in the bright blue sky She frowned What does it mean, Anna Pa asked anxiously It means a change is coming, she said A good one or a bad one Violet asked Ma shook her head Just a change She looked at Pa It could be good or bad Pa stood silent for a moment.The moon is only the beginning of the superstitions There s everything from empty buckets, seeing spiders in the morning, shirts buttoned incorrectly, shoes on a table, and so much What I love about the superstitions is how well they were done It could easily have turned into an annoyance but ended up as an endearing, and often entertaining, aspect of the story.What the Moon Said has strong characters that made me care Ma is a hard woman a woman who doles out affection sparingly, and is affectionate although, not by much with Esther s siblings than she ever is with Esther leading Esther to believe that her mother doesn t love her If only Ma would hug her and say, It will be all right That would make the trembling stop, Esther was sure And if Ma loved Esther , she might say and do these things But Ma did not love her enough Not yet.Esther s heartache over this dilemma completely tore me apart While there were times that I grew tired of hearing about her fear that Ma didn t love her because it is said a whole heck of a lot , I also understand that children are really capable of honing in on one subject and drilling it into the ground I know mine do In other words, Esther s fear is believable.Navigating through changes, new friendships, lost friendships, and loneliness with Esther was a journey that I enjoyed being on While the times weren t always happy in fact, they were often downright depressing no pun intended the story felt very realistic This is a strong piece of historical fiction for children or anyone who just loves to read books, despite the intended age range myself included, obviously that provides a fine example of life during the Depression.

  3. says:

    What the Moon Said What the Moon Said is one of the best books I have read in a long time yet it is for eight to twelve year olds I found it a beautiful read set in the time of the great depression in America The main character is little Esther and the themes in the book are centered on this child Sometimes she is the narrator when for example she describes her bewilderment at some of the painful issues between her Mother and herself Her Father is American and her Mother is Russian and is fanatical in her superstitious nature This aspect of her character runs through the whole story causing Esther in particular problems in whether to believe them or not The large family, all girls except the youngest child, face the unexpected risk of poverty when the Father loses his job in the city and decides to put what savings they have into purchasing a farm out in the country Little Esther, a dreamy imaginative child lives a dual life When things are too hard for Esther to bear, she retreats into her private dream world where she can escape from the pain of reality often conversing with her beloved doll This often gets her into trouble Esther longs to feel loved by her Mother who spends all of her days working hard to keep her family fed and clothed Esther cannot seem to sense this love no matter how she tries to please her Mother She is sure in her heart that she is not good enough to be loved and often makes unfavourable comparisons concerning her Mother s attitude towards her elder sister and younger brother in contrast to how her Mother treats her This fear is manifested primarily in her relationship with her superstitious Russian Mother Esther sees her Mother as someone who is always irritated, disappointed or even angry with her In her mind she does not have her Mother s approval, so to escape from this pain she retreats into her imaginary world where her Mother is all loving She does endure a lot of emotional stress for because of her low self esteem for she herself does make many mistakes in her efforts in general to receive love Esther doesn t realise how often her hard pressed Mother is irritated by her own constant day dreaming when she should be doing things her Mother has asked her to do.In the latter part of the book, the harsh conditions during the long hard winter escalates, causing the family and their animals to suffer general hardship Hunger is their greatest enemy Food has run out and the family are starving and in desperate need It is at this point that dramatic events now take place leading to Esther being returned to Chicago to stay with her big sister Julie.It is in this latter part of the book Esther finally begins to learn the truth about love and the acceptance of reality rather than forever escaping into her imaginary world with her beloved doll to find it She discovers what it actually means to her alone, rather than having her big sister Julie s explanation She discovers that love is not just about hugs and kisses She at last learns that words can be the smallest part of loving The continuing struggle with the state of affairs on the farm now causes the whole family to have to come back to Chicago This is where the author ties up all the loose ends to finish the story.Earlier in the book, Esther had longed for her own Mother to give her hugs and kisses in the way her best friend received so many from her own stoic Mother At the end of the book she learns that her friend s Mother had left the family to run off with a lover She might not be so demonstrative and she causes issues with her superstitious nature, but her love for her family shines through all the hard work and dedication in the way she gives her whole life to keeping the family together no matter how hard the choices she has to make She improvises, no matter what dark clouds of troubles swirl around them One small issue I do have with the ending is that it feels a little rushed It is almost as if that now Esther problems are ironed out she isn t sure where to go next, for Esther is without doubt the major character This is just my personal impression though and others might not agree with me.I had a constant lump in my throat during most of the second half of the book and found myself fighting tears I identified with this lonely little girl She tries so hard to please her Mother as the story unfolds.As a child and into my teens even, I also struggled with my perception of an undemonstrative Mother that I carried inside of me for various personal reasons I seemed to be a disappointment to her no matter how hard I tried.I recommend this book highly I enjoyed it as an adult It would also be ideal to read with your children or to them.

  4. says:

    An outstanding MG novel that I m sure will become a favorite of students and teachers alike I was completely captivated by this historical fiction novel, which takes place during the Depression Esther is a young girl struggling to get her mom s approval and love Her mom is very superstitious and these superstitions guide Esther s enter family, determining the good luck and bad luck they ll have At times, it s frustrating, hurtful, and confusing for Esther, especially when she is forbidden to play with a girl she really likes as a friend Readers will move with Esther and her family from Chicago to a farm in Milwaukee They ll experience hunger, they ll celebrate the holidays with them, they ll go through Esther s illness and recovery Even though the novel takes place a good eighty years ago, readers will be able to relate to the characters Family, friendship, and being neighborly are some of the bigger themes of this novel It ll has a timeless appeal like Little Women and Little House on the Prairie.This MG novel is a winner

  5. says:

    A sad but happy book I wish in the ending Ma would have done something than just smile at her, but I m not the author.

  6. says:

    What The Moon Said is to me, a story about the real meaning of love.All through their challenges during the great recession, Esther tried over and over to make her mother show her that she loves her She wanted her mother to hug her and tell her she loves her In the end, after many hardships and tears and painful moments she realized things are never white or black.I lost count of all the many moments I saw similarities between Esther s life and my own childhood Some of them are too personal to share on the internet Others have a bittersweet taste like I remember making cones out of old newspapers as a kid so I could go sell roasted peanuts during summer breaks with my cousins.Esther s family went through a lot and her mother s superstition didn t help much However I loved that even the mother had to learn the hard way that sometimes signs could be wrong or better yet they could mean nothing at all I love that this book showed in a vivid and poignant way that maybe real love is to stick together when life get rough, when life gets so gloom and dark and hopeless that you can only hope to make it till tomorrow, and maybe the day after and so on.This is a quiet book but a very powerful one It teaches a lot of lessons but not in a preachy way You see everything Esther feels You are right there in her thoughts You struggle with her over what decision is the right one You get angry with her when she fails over and over to make her mother see her when she s doing good things, great things, and not when she messes up.I remembered all those feelings and I was shocked at how raw some of them still were, after so many years This book needs to get into the hands of every kid.I apologize this review is so personal On a lighter note, if you enjoy books like The Little House on The Prairie you might enjoy What The Moon Said And if you accidentally knocked over salt don t forget to throw some over your left shoulder Just in case, because you never know.

  7. says:

    A ring around the moon is an omen of bad things to come Ten year old Esther doesn t know whether or not she believes her Ma s superstitions, but the moon s warning seems to come true when her father loses his job in Chicago The year is 1930 and the nation is in the grip of the Great Depression City jobs are impossible to find Esther and her family move to a ramshackle farm in Wisconsin to eke a living out of the land There is no electricity or plumbing, but Esther is excited about the move There are horses and cows and, best of all, a dog Not wanting to bring misfortune, Esther does her best to follow her Ma s rules But life is not simple when a sign of bad luck means that Esther must turn her back on the only friend she has Esther is caught between loyalty to her Ma and her own heart, all while trying to survive the harsh Wisconsin winter.Rosengren s WHAT THE MOON SAID is a large hearted debut It is my favorite kind of historical fiction, making a long ago time feel as real and relatable as current day While some of Esther s struggles farm life and gripping poverty may be unfamiliar to some young readers, Esther s deepest wishes will hit very close to home Readers will easily see themselves in Esther s desire to understand her place in the family, her need for friendship, and her pleasure in everyday adventure.

  8. says:

    So bittersweet I want to give Esther a hugno, not just one hugALL THE HUGS Knowing that Esther s book is based on the real experiences of author s mother made the story events hit so much closer And I love the ending Without giving away too much, it s hopeful but realistic I d recommend this book to fans of the Little House on the Prairie series.

  9. says:

    What a perfect historical fiction middle grade novel it is right on the nose for about age 8 10, the perfect next step for children who have outgrown books like Mary Pope Osborne s Magic Tree House series This will greatly appeal to fans of the Little House in the Big Woods series I love the chapter heading art by Jonathan Bean Building Our House Lends itself to so many educational extension activities sure to become a great favorite of teachers and homeschooling families.

  10. says:

    This story combines the best of a classic vignette based tale with elements seldom found in books for this age Set in an early year of the depression, it spans life in a Chicago apartment and a rural SE Wisconsin farm community Esther deals with some self inflicted angst about not being loved as much as her siblings, but also faces the power and fears conveyed by her mother s strict adherence to old world superstitions Throughout it all she takes tentative steps toward maturity, gaining perspective and appreciation for her family Esther and her stories will stay with me.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *